Breaking News
More () »

Austin's Leading Local News: Weather, Traffic, Sports and more | Austin, Texas | KVUE.com

Boston Scientific mesh surgery settlement too late for some victims

The KVUE Defenders last visited with Carmen Pacheco in 2019. Carmen died in December 2020 at the age of 56.

AUSTIN, Texas — Editor's note: The video above was published in 2019.

Texas is set to get millions as part of a settlement with Boston Scientific over claims that the company deceptively marketed mesh devices to consumers.

This is the largest settlement involving mesh used for pelvic organ prolapse, a condition one in five women suffer from typically following childbirth, where pelvic muscles no longer support pelvic organs. Boston Scientific agreed to pay 47 states more than $188,655,067 million. Texas is set to receive $13 million of that. But it is too little too late for some women.

The KVUE Defenders last visited with Carmen Pacheco in 2019. She died in December 2020 at the age of 56.

"I've been in and out of the hospital about 60-70 times since I've had this," she said in April 2019.

RELATED: After 3 hernia surgeries, 60-plus hospital visits, woman regrets surgical mesh

In 2013 doctors implanted in Pacheco plastic mesh for pelvic order prolapse and a hernia. This once-active mom spent her remaining years confined to her home.

"I can't do anything now,” she said last spring. “I can't even eat."

Pacheco is not the only patient who said she was left suffering after pelvic mesh surgery.

"This is affecting lives and it's major, and no one is really listening to us," said Barbara Melling, a patient who is suffering from complications of surgical mesh.

For years, thousands of women complained to the FDA about chronic pain, urinary dysfunction and a new onset of incontinence. And Boston Scientific apologized at a hearing in 2019.

"I want to express my deepest sympathy and my sincere empathy to all of the women who have been harmed by surgical mesh therapy," said Dr. Ronald Morton Jr. back in February 2019.

Following that hearing and KVUE Defenders reports, the FDA ordered companies to stop using transvaginal surgical mesh implants for pelvic order prolapse in 2019.

Even since then, in 2019 and 2020 1,547 women have complained about complications of mesh from their surgeries.

This settlement is the latest move by states to hold companies accountable. However, Boston Scientific said the settlement was not an admission of misconduct or liability.

Johnson & Johnson and its Ethicon unit reached a similar $117 million multistate settlement in 2019 and Becton Dickinson and Co. and its CR Bard unit reached a $60 million agreement last September.

Despite their years of suffering, many victims will see very little, if any, of this settlement money.

WATCH: Surgical mesh leaves Austin woman struggling to survive


Police: Florida mom shows up to daughter's school wearing boxing glove, fights child, gets arrested

Sneaky serpents: Texas Department of Agriculture reminds Texans to keep sharp eye out for snakes

Majority of Austin council members oppose Prop F, a ballot measure that would change City’s type of government