AUSTIN, Texas — Austin Public Health's Dr. Mark Escott provided Travis County Commissioners with COVID-19 updates on Tuesday and said schools aren't designed to socially distance students.
He also said that in-person classes could lead to anywhere between 40 to more than 1,300 deaths among students in Travis County alone.
"There's a lot of steps that still need to be done and we're not going to be able to get there. The schools are not going to be able to get there before the beginning of September," said Escott.
Round Rock and Leander ISD board of trustees ask TEA to suspend in-person learning until COVID-19 cases decrease
Escott's COVID-19 School Preliminary Recommendations include:
- Delay the start of school or offer virtual-only instruction at least until Sept. 8
- Development of risk-based guidelines for K-12 schools
- Refinement of recommendations from CDC and TEA to better establish expectations for school systems
- Consider a default position of virtual instruction for the duration of the fall semester
"We're talking about hundreds and thousands of people when we talk about the school systems," said Escott. "When we look at students, we know that the risk of students having severe illness or death is relatively small compared to others. When we look at our data from March and April, our rate of deaths in the 10-19 age group was zero, but we have to also be aware that we had a relatively small number of cases."
Escott said when APH looks at other data sets in terms of people in this age group and the risk associated with hospitalization and death, APH has data out of China that indicates the risk of death is estimated to be 0.18%.
"This is a little bit of a challenge with the numbers because you hear 0.18% and the translation is, 'Well, my child has a 99% chance of not dying from COVID-19,'" said Escott. "The real number, because the numbers are small related to COVID-19 cases and deaths ... it's hard to be certain about the estimate of the case fatality rate."
Escott said the estimated actual case fatality rate in the 10 to 19 age group is somewhere between 0.03% and 1.02%.
"Unless we have a vaccine quickly, somewhere in the neighborhood of 70% of students could be infected over the course of this disease," said Escott.
"In that .03% to 1.02%, for Travis County, would equate to between 40 and 1,370 deaths in that age group. Again, these are sobering numbers and we have to be very very careful when we hear people talking about the percentage of people who do OK with this because there is a number behind the other side of that, behind the people who die, behind the people who are hospitalized and it is a very sobering number," said Escott.
Escott explained that the risk for faculty and staff is much higher. He said, "somewhere in the neighborhood of two to 10 times higher in terms of rates of death."
Another challenge Escott mentioned is when people, particularly staff, get sick in school.
"The practicality of social distancing in almost all of our school is in almost all or all of our schools is a challenge. Our schools are not designed for having desks six feet apart," said Escott. "All of our districts would have to triple the size of schools, triple the size of spaces in order to achieve that. So what can be done if you can't achieve that? You can build plexiglass barriers in between the desks. You can orchestrate rotations of schedules, flows of hallways, masking of students."
Escott said those plans aren't in place right now and it would take school districts time to implement them.
"Right now at Stage 4, and certainly at Stage 5, it would be very dangerous for us to open up schools. We've seen this happen over and over and over again. Israel, South Korea, other parts of the world that opened when disease was still spreading substantially in the community, to close within a week or two weeks because of outbreaks in those schools. We've got a lot of work to do and I look forward to ongoing discussions with our superintendents and other members of the community," said Escott.
PEOPLE ARE ALSO READING: