Breaking News
More () »

'It's nonsense' | City and State officials still won't name nursing homes with coronavirus outbreaks

The City of Austin reports 15 senior living center patients in the city have died from the virus.

AUSTIN, Texas — Austin Public Health is inspecting clusters of COVID-19 at eight local senior care facilities, meaning there are three or more cases of the virus at each facility.

But Texans still don’t know which nursing homes in Texas have coronavirus cases or how bad the outbreaks are.

"They might tell me she's dead two weeks after it happens," said Jose Hernandez, whose mom, Leonila, lives at West Oaks Nursing and Rehabilitation Center in South Austin. "That's my biggest fear. I don't want that. I want to know what's going on with my mom."

Hernandez is one of many people who have told the KVUE Defenders they’re desperate for more information about the spread of COVID-19 where their loved ones live.

RELATED: Austin-Travis County health authority issues updated control orders for nursing homes, long-term care facilities

The Texas Health and Human Services Commission (HHSC) released new numbers Monday showing 238 nursing homes have at least one case of the virus, which is more than 19% of all those facilities in the state. There have been 130 residents who have died.

As for assisted living facilities, there are 69 with at least one case of the virus, which is about 3%. And there have been 34 coronavirus-related deaths in those facilities.

But still, the City and State refuse to tell people where those nursing homes are and how many cases and deaths each one has. 

RELATED: South Austin nursing home confirms staffer died days after KVUE Defenders pushed for answers on COVID-19 cases

Both agencies cite State and federal personal health privacy laws, like HIPAA, as the reason they won’t disclose that information.

"It’s nonsense to claim that HIPAA bars telling the public where COVID cases are erupting," UT Austin Law Professor Elizabeth Sepper said. 

Sepper said disclosing facility locations, case numbers and death totals wouldn’t violate any personal health privacy laws.

"Texas is using HIPPA as a convenient excuse," Sepper said. "Which, HIPAA is often a convenient excuse to withhold information."

HIPAA is a federal law, meaning it would apply to every state. But California, New York, Florida, Nevada, Colorado and New Jersey have started releasing facility names and case information. 

RELATED: Texas nursing home deaths rise as families beg for information

Family members like Hernandez are hoping Texas follows suit.

"They have to provide more information to us so we know what the real situation is happening in there," Hernandez said.

A spokesperson for the HHSC said other health privacy laws besides HIPAA prevent the agency from releasing the information. 

The federal government announced Sunday that nursing homes are now required to report COVID-19 cases and deaths to family members, state health departments and the CDC.

RELATED: Coronavirus spreads through Texas nursing homes. The State doesn't want you to know where

KVUE asked the State to confirm facility names given these new guidelines, but representatives from Health and Human Services still refuse.

"CMS issued information indicating it will now require nursing facilities to report information to CDC and keep residents and their family members informed about conditions at the facilities," HHSC spokesperson Kelli Weldon said in an email. "The directive indicates that CMS will put forth rules requiring this reporting to federal and state authorities. The information does not indicate CMS will impose a reporting requirement on the state regulatory agency."

WATCH: Lawmaker calls for details on Texas nursing homes with coronavirus


Before You Leave, Check This Out