Leaders in the City of Austin have talked for years about the need to create affordable housing and Austin has incentives for developers to build more affordable homes. But the KVUE Defenders looked into a system that allows developers to pay the city in order to avoid providing affordable housing.
Middle-class dreams dashed
As the skyline has grown, so has the cost of living in this boomtown, leaving many long-time – and in some cases life-long – residents feeling shut out.
"To even find anything, even a one-bedroom is like a thousand dollars in the city limits," said former Austin resident Elijah Zuniga.
The dream of a comfortable life led Zuniga and his wife 50 miles northeast of Austin to Thorndale. They now have an hour-long commute from the tiny Williamson County suburb.
Zuniga is an electrician and his wife is a medical technician. Both earn decent middle-class salaries but are not where they expected to be at the age of 30.
“We're at the point where we'd like a house, but we can't even afford a house because housing is so expensive [in Austin]," Zuniga explained.
He and his wife are among a growing middle-class population that feels Austin is increasingly out of reach.
Rent rising faster than Austin families can afford
According to a city survey, 43% of residents surveyed said they were displaced because their rent was rising above what their household could afford. It’s a statistic that resonates with Zuniga and his wife.
"The cost of living here has gone up so much faster than the actual ability to pay for it," he said. “That's why the city government needs to provide incentives to create affordable housing."
Developer incentives in the City of Austin
The City of Austin does provide incentives for housing developers.
There are currently a dozen different programs designed to help add more affordable housing with benefits for developers. But, increasingly, more developers are paying “fees in lieu” of affordable housing to the city when they decide to build.
The KVUE Defenders discovered the developers of 54 projects have paid nearly $8.3 million in “fees in lieu” of affordable housing to the City in the last 15 years. Most of those developments have fewer than 15% affordable units. Seven of them provided no affordable housing units at all.
This interactive map shows where those 54 projects are across Austin and how much those developers paid in "fees in lieu" of affordable housing.
According to city records, the developer of a project in the Domain paid $581,536 to avoid providing affordable units.
City records also show a developer paid $868,240 to avoid building affordable units at a complex on Nueces Street formerly called Rise, which is now owned by Wyndham Hotels.
The developer of The Independent paid the City $2,477,490 in fees not to provide affordable units. The lowest-priced condo there is selling for $529,000 and gets you less than 700 square feet of living space.
An Austin developer weighs in
Perry Lorenz is a real estate investor and developer who has been working in Austin for 42 years. His company helped build The Independent and other residential complexes in Austin. Lorenz told KVUE costs have increased too.
“Downtown land prices have doubled in three or four years, in some cases tripled. Usually, that takes generations,” he said.
Lorenz said that's one of the reasons developers choose to just pay the fee.
“If you're moving someone into a unit at $500 a square foot, it's a working-class family, it's a three-bedroom, they've got four kids. Do you want to put them in a million-and-a-half-dollar unit in a high rise downtown? Or do you want to go buy four or five times as many units in a neighborhood?” said Lorenz. “That's why I think most developers end up contributing to the trust fund rather than building it on site. It gets you more housing and it's just easier.”
Austin City Council: The developer fees are not enough
Austin City Council members agree the fees developers are paying are not enough and it’s a problem the city needs to address.
"We have created so many roadblocks in creating affordable housing,” said City Council Member Sabino “Pio” Renteria, who represents District 3 in East Austin.
"That 'fee in lieu' program right now is too small,” said Jimmy Flannigan, a council member representing District 6.
Flannigan showed KVUE around the latest affordable housing development in his northwest Austin district. Lakeline Station cost about $30 million to build with funding from a partnership between the non-profit Foundation Communities along with private and local government interests. All 128 units at Lakeline Station are full and so is the waitlist.
"The need is much greater than what the City and the market are able to provide," Flannigan said.
Lorenz said an increase in the "fees in lieu" of affordable housing would only be passed on.
“It would just simply mean a higher fee would be attached to the development which means you raise your prices,” Lorenz said.
Affordable housing by the numbers
Since 2015, the number of housing units created has dropped from 1,665 to 661 in 2019.
“It’s not something that the government alone can fix,” Councilmember Flannigan said. “It’s also not something that the private market alone can fix.”
Right now, there are 23 major construction projects underway across Austin and another 16 are planned.
Austin’s boomtown growth includes hotels, office space and residential living space.
Since 1993, 25,439 affordable housing units have been created in Austin. Twenty-five percent of those were created in the last six years.
Last year the City set a goal to create 60,000 affordable housing units in 10 years. Councilmember Renteria isn’t optimistic about reaching that goal.
“It's going to be very difficult,” Renteria said. “We'll probably reach 10,000 in 10 years, maybe 15.”
“The affordable housing we have on the ground today is more of a response to the smaller moves made five and 10 years ago,” Flannigan said. “Developments don't happen overnight. You don't pass a new land development code and immediately bulldozers are hitting the streets.”
The 2018 affordable housing bond
Voters also approved a 2018 bond dedicating $250 million to affordable housing.
“It's also not true that you pass a bond and that immediately turns into affordable housing. We have hundreds of millions of dollars – voter-approved – to build for affordable housing, and we are getting those dollars expended,” Flannigan said. “We will see a lot more affordable housing hit the streets in the next two, three, four and five years.”
Several new affordable housing projects are in the approval and planning process now.
At the same time, 10 more developers are set to pay another $12 million in fees instead of providing affordable housing, which isn’t enough money to build another Lakeline Station. Another 11 developers have yet to have their fees calculated.
This interactive map shows pending developments that are paying "fees in lieu" of affordable housing across Austin.
In the next four years, Austin is set to lose another 5,000 income-restricted units that were funded or built with incentives for developers from the City. The “affordability period” for those units expires by 2024.
Being middle-class in Austin means having a longer commute
Meanwhile, a long commute is likely to be the norm for a growing number of average, middle-class families.
“I've got people from my company coming all the way from Seguin, Killeen,” said Zuniga. “One person who goes to my class works in Austin and lives in College Station.”
Section 23-4E-5040 mentions alternatives to providing affordable housing. This is the only mention of the “fee in-lieu” in the land development code draft.
This story brought up a host of other affordability questions and you can count on the KVUE Defenders to keep digging. If you have any questions email Terri Gruca or reach out to her on Facebook, Twitter or Instagram.
PEOPLE ARE ALSO READING: