Local News
Judge denies temporary block of $5 strip club fee 
06:44 PM CST on Tuesday, December 18, 2007
A judge denied a request Tuesday from owners of nude entertainment clubs to temporarily block Texas' upcoming $5-per-person strip club fee from taking effect.
Judge Scott Jenkins said he was not persuaded that there was "imminent irreparable harm," so he denied a temporary injunction request made by the Texas Entertainment Association and Karpod, Inc., owner of an Amarillo club.
Jenkins said he would rule on a future date on the state's motions to dismiss the clubs' lawsuit over the new fee. If he doesn't dismiss the case, it could proceed to trial.
The $5 charge goes into effect Jan. 1. The clubs' first payments to the state are to be made in April.
"The injury is going to start on Jan. 1. It's not just likely, it's going to happen," plantiffs' attorney Stewart Whitehead told the judge. He and other lawyers for the plaintiff said the fee amounted to an unfair tax and that it violates constitutional rights to free expression.
State attorneys said the $5 per customer surcharge will be fairly imposed "on a level playing field" to all nude entertainment clubs and won't violate First Amendment rights.
The clubs' association sued Texas Attorney General Greg Abbott and Comptroller Susan Combs earlier this month.
The new fee, approved this year by the Texas Legislature, is projected to raise some $44 million for sexual assault prevention programs and health care for the uninsured. The state's attorneys tried to suggest through questioning of their witnesses that there are links between sexually oriented businesses and sexual assaults.
Chandra Brown, president of Karpod, which owns Players' night club in Amarillo, testified her club would go out of business if it has to collect an additional $5-per-patron charge.
"They won't pay it. They won't come in," she said. "They can't afford it."
Currently the club charges a $4 cover charge, she said, noting that when it tried to increase the admission fee to $5 per person it lost business.
Scott Burch, president of the Texas Entertainment Association, who called the clubs "adult cabarets," testified that customers will go elsewhere if nude entertainment clubs charge too much admission.
"You can only charge so much to the customer before they will go bowling, Bennigans, X, Y, Z," he said.
In a brief filed by the state, on behalf of Abbott and Combs, attorneys argued that the fee "does not prohibit nude dancing, does not dictate where live nude entertainment may be presented, does not require any minimum clothing and does not govern the physical setting for the activity."
More headlines
News, Photos & More
KVUE on your Desktop: Get traffic, radar and up-to-the-minute headlines on your desktop.
Keep Up: Have KVUE headlines delivered to your RSS reader.
Find out what's happening: Check our Events calendar to find events near you.
Most popular KVUE.com stories
Most E-mailed News
Popular Stories






You must be logged in to contribute. Log in | Register Now!
You are logged in as screenname | Log Out
You are logged in, but do not have a "screen" name. Update Your Profile